Logo


Helping parents and professionals make sense of children's behavior.
  Lawrence Kutner Ph.D.
  
Mother and Child
Parenting Advice
Articles
Bookshelf
Online Resources
Mailing List
Subscribe to Dr. Kutner's Monthly Articles.
HTML Text

   
  Heartbroken

Insights for Parents:
What do you do when your child's heart is broken?

The breakup of an older adolescent's long-term relationship can be very painful, for the child and occasionally for the adult as well. We may vicariously feel our child's hurt, disappointment, and anger. It is, at best, an awkward situation. Yet this experience may provide parents and children with an opportunity to learn about one another at a different level and begin a new stage of their relationship.

In the late 1980s, Dr. Terri L. Orbuch, a social psychologist at the University of Michigan, studied 150 college students and non-students to find out how they handled the breakup of long-term relationships. She found that late adolescents were more likely to go to their friends for support than to their parents because, they said, they thought their friends would take their situation more seriously.

One of the most striking findings was the differences in the ways men and women tended to handle the stress of the breakup. Women this age were more likely to seek advice from family members and friends. Men were more likely to respond to the breakup by spending more time in competitive sports.

Other studies have indicated the tendency of young women to be more verbal and young men more physical in their attempts to recover from broken relationships. While this may sound strikingly similar to the way boys and girls in early elementary school handle stressful events, this time it can't be attributed largely to differences in verbal skills.

Instead, it seems to be linked to how they feel others will respond to their descriptions of what happened. Young women describe sharing the story of their breakup as something that helps them grow closer to their peers because they feel more comfortable sharing such intimacies. Young men tend to be much less comfortable talking to each other this way. They may view the breakup as a failure on their part, and therefore a poor reflection on themselves.

You also shouldn't assume that men bounce back more easily than women do from a love affair gone sour, or that women are more likely to be "dumped" than men are. Research by Dr. Charles T. Hill of Whittier College in California found that several of the commonly held assumptions about the differences between how men and women perceive relationships are false. Starting in the mid 1970s, he followed 231 college-age couples who said that they were seeing each other exclusively. He found that 50 percent had broken up within fifteen years.

In contrast to the stereotype, Dr. Hill found that in his sample, women were more likely to be the ones to break up with their partners. He and others have also found that men are more likely to hold starry-eyed beliefs such as that true love lasts forever and that love can overcome all obstacles.

Finally, there are certain times of year when young love is likely to come to an end, and therefore when parents are more likely to see its ramifications. Studies of long-term teenage relationships have found that young couples tend to break up at the beginning or end of the school year, or over Christmas break. These are, perhaps, the easiest times to end a relationship because the changes in an adolescent's schedule increase the likelihood of quickly meeting another partner.

RESPONDING TO THE BREAKUP

So what can you do if your son or daughter has just split up with a long-term sweetheart? Here are some things to keep in mind:

  • Don't rush in with advice. Many parents feel uncomfortable in this situation because it reminds them of painful episodes from their own adolescence. Remember that a breakup can be like a death, and a teenager (and an adult as well) may need to go through a certain amount of mourning to resolve it.

    Giving advice will probably make your child feel worse because it sets the two of you up in old roles, and may emphasize his feelings of inadequacy or incompetence. Instead, acknowledge, what he is saying and let him know what emotions you are hearing in his voice. This shows him that you are listening, and helps him think through the situation.

  • Gently encourage your child to discuss how he feels about himself after a breakup. This is particularly important for young men, since many feel uncomfortable disclosing emotions, especially those that could be interpreted as signs of weakness.

    If your child doesn't want to talk, don't try to force the issue. Let your child take the initiative to express his feelings in his own way. Applying too much pressure before your child is ready will make him even more hesitant to discuss the problem. Instead, tell him that you're available if he wants to talk.

Don't worry if your child never talks to you about the situation. That simply means that he felt more comfortable, at that moment, confiding in someone else.

  • Don't dismiss or deny the significance of the relationship. In an effort to be reassuring, parents sometimes say things like, "By the time you're thirty, you'll have forgotten all about this." But diminishing the problem will probably make your child feel worse since she now feels rejected by her parents as well. Besides, by the time she's thirty, she will not have forgotten all about this relationship; she simply will have changed her perspective on it.

  • Keep your opinions of the former girlfriend or boyfriend to yourself. It's tempting to lash out at the person associated with your child's pain. But keep in mind that people who have recently broken up, especially adolescents, often have ambivalent feelings about each other. If you criticize the former boyfriend, your child may feel even more uncomfortable and may begin to defend him.

 

  
Top | Home | About | Parenting Advice | Speaking/Consulting | For Health Professionals | Contact | Search
 
 

Web design by flyte new media
email Web Master