Logo


Helping parents and professionals make sense of children's behavior.
  Lawrence Kutner Ph.D.
  
Mother and Child
Parenting Advice
Articles
Bookshelf
Online Resources
Mailing List
Subscribe to Dr. Kutner's Monthly Articles.
HTML Text

   
  Stepsibling Rivalry

Insights for Parents:
Stepsibling Rivalry

At first the two eight-year-olds treated each other with the wariness of two hungry cats that suddenly have to share the same food bowl. They had, until David's father decided to marry Kay's mother, each spent most of their lives as the only child of single parents. Now that was changing. David and his father had moved into Kay's home.

The teasing, tattling and tussles that routinely mark sibling rivalry can become a special problem for blended families. "Only" children have to learn to share a parent's affection and attention. Cries of "Mom always liked you best!" can have a sharp and bitter edge. Parent often feel as if they are being tugged in opposing directions by their feelings of love and protectiveness for their children and their new spouse.

Children undergo a large number of dramatic and subtle changes when they inter a blended family. Parents often underestimate the extent and importance of those changes.

Private space is a major area of conflict for stepsiblings. The dickering over who gets which bedroom or who has to share a bedroom can make political negotiations in the Middle East pale by comparison. If as is often the case, one side of the family moves into a house or apartment that the other side has been living in, the territorial squabbles can grow very bitter. The children who have already been in the house and who already have their own turf staked out feel imposed upon and threatened. The entering children feel more out of place than their new stepsiblings do.

Birth order becomes confused in blended families. Most children define their roles within the family partially in terms of where they are among their siblings. After a remarriage, a girl who has been the oldest for ten years may suddenly have two big stepsisters. A boy who was the baby of the family suddenly loses the advantages of that position to a stepsibling.

Holidays can become arenas of strong conflict for blended families, especially for the first year or two. Each set of children, unsure of what the new family means for their future, clutches at the past by insisting that its is the "right" way to celebrate. Christmas trees are divided in half so that each set of children can decorate it "properly."

Age plays a major role in determining how children respond to their new families. Teenagers often have more difficulty than younger children do in adapting to blended families. Parents wonder if the apparently rebellious adolescent who stays away from the house and doesn't participate in planned family activities is trying to sabotage the new family.

Often the problem is not the child's attitude but a conflict between the stage of development of the child and the stage of the new stepfamily. Separating from family and developing an individual identity are among the major developmental tasks of adolescence. It is important that teenagers place some distance between themselves and what they perceive as the dependent behavior of their childhood. Spending time with friends away from home and arguing over parental restrictions are ways of safely testing the turbid waters of adulthood.

The newly formed stepfamily, however, is at a developmental stage much closer to that of a younger child. Parents strive for the new family to be surrounded by the symbols of harmony and closeness. The adolescent perceives those same symbols as signs that the very dependence he is trying to escape. The more the parents promote togetherness, the more the teenagers strive for separation, both from their parents and from their new stepsiblings. By recognizing a teenager's desire to spend time away from family and with friends as a sign of normal development, rather than by forcing the child to spend time with family, parents can help their children form bonds with the new family in the most appropriate and long-lasting ways.

High schools seniors and other teenagers who are about to leave home may have a very different reaction to a parent's remarriage from that of younger adolescents. While a fifteen-year-old may rebel against the new family, an eighteen-year-old will often embrace it. The soon-to-depart child is often relieved that someone else will be able to take care of his or her parent.

Before trying to put a stop to all stepsibling rivalry, recognize that, as with other forms of rivalry, some aspects of it are very healthy. The competition allows children to practice some new roles. It also allows them to figure out for themselves the types of relationships they want with their new family members. If you try to turn them into an all-loving instant family, the children will simply rebel by showing you how much they can't stand each other. Remember that your strongest ally is time. Give your children and yourselves a chance to stumble about a bit as you sort through the new relationships.

If you would like to email a copy of this article to a friend please complete the form below.

 Your name:
Your email:
Their name:
Their email:
Would you like to add a message? (Optional)

 

  
Top | Home | About | Parenting Advice | Speaking/Consulting | For Health Professionals | Contact | Search
 
 

Web design by flyte new media
email Web Master